My pickled veg is fizzing – is it OK? | Kitchen aide (2024)

I pickled some small home-grown cucumbers in spiced and sweetened vinegar, packed tightly into a lidded jar. The liquid leaked out of the jar, it had cloudy patches and it was fizzing. Are my pickles still OK?
Helen, Newent, Gloucestershire

What a, er, pickle. Whether or not these cucumbers should be discarded is hard to say without knowing exactly what went into Helen’s brine, says Rachel de Thample, author of The River Cottage Fermentation Handbook. What we do know, however, is that pickled cucumbers are tricky to get right, so she should cut herself some slack.

“What’s happened is that fermentation has taken place,” De Thample says. “The cucumbers most likely had a high water content and, if they were put into the jar whole, then that water will leak out.” Obviously, gauging how much water is in your cukes is nigh on impossible, so it’s best to salt them the night before. This, De Thample says, draws out excess moisture (you rinse off the salt later) and “helps lower the pH, which creates an environment where the bad bacteria can’t multiply.” For a fermented brine, you normally add 4% salt (that is, 4g salt per 100ml), but, De Thample says, watery veg can dilute this, so try upping it to 8-10%.

Always use sea salt, too, advises Kylee Newton, author of The Modern Preserver, because “some iodised salt can create a cloudy, white residue.” Also check that your brine recipe has a “healthy proportion of 5% high-acid vinegar”, Newton adds, “to make your pickles last longer”, and always leave it to cool before pouring over the cucumbers. Then add spices (mustard seeds, allspice berries, black peppercorns, coriander or dill seeds) and something from the allium family: “Shallots, onions or spring onions, leeks, garlic [cloves bashed or thinly sliced] or wild garlic [when in season] will add a really lovely back note,” De Thample says. And don’t be alarmed if your garlic changes colour: “It sometimes goes a greeny/blue [due to a chemical reaction]; it looks freaky, but it’s fine.”

You don’t want to pack that jar too tightly, either: “The vegetables must be completely submerged under the brine with only a 2mm gap between the brine and lid,” Newton says, “and I use a chopstick to move out any trapped bubbles that might encourage other bacteria in those spaces.” For longer preservation, you’re also going to want to store those cucumbers in the fridge.

There are other ways to ease yourself into pickling, too, Helen, so don’t lose heart. While it’s worth persevering with those homegrown cucumbers, also consider heading to your nearest east European deli come next summer. “A lot of Polish-style pickles use varieties of cucumbers that are drier and have thicker skins,” De Thample says, “and this guarantees success.” Alternatively, make friends with quick pickles: “My grandmother used to cut cucumbers from the garden, add apple cider vinegar and a pinch of salt, and leave them on the table for a couple hours before dinner.” (You might want to sweeten the deal with a little honey, mind).

My pickled veg is fizzing – is it OK? | Kitchen aide (2024)

FAQs

My pickled veg is fizzing – is it OK? | Kitchen aide? ›

“A lot of times when microorganisms grow, as part of the fermentation process they produce carbon dioxide gas,” she says. “And so definitely don't eat anything that's discolored or fizzing.”

Is it okay to eat pickles that are fizzy? ›

Pickled-caused food poisoning is very rare. "With a fresh pickle like ours, if you see the top of the lid domed up or bubbled, this typically means the product has fermented and gone bad," says Eddie Andre, director of brand experience at Grillo's Pickles.

Why is my pickle jar fizzing? ›

What happens if a jar of Real Pickles is left out of refrigeration? The fermentation process will resume. After a few hours at warm temperatures, some carbonation may develop in the jar, leading to a fizzy or tingling sensation on the tongue.

Should pickles sizzle? ›

Traditional pickles are fermented and can fizz when opened. A dead giveaway that you have fermented pickles is that the liquid is kind of murky-white. We are more used to vinegar pickles, which are not fermented and do not fizz.

Why do my pickles have bubbles? ›

It's true that lacto-fermentation does produce carbon dioxide and you will frequently see bubbles forming in the jar; however, sometimes carbon dioxide is produced and makes it's way up through the top of the fermentation so efficiently that you don't see it.

How can you tell that your fermented pickles are not safe to eat? ›

If it feels very soft and mushy, or the texture is different than usual, they're definitely not safe to eat. If you're ever unsure or if you feel like your pickles might be bad, it's always better to err on the side of caution. Remember, to avoid foodborne illness — when in doubt, throw it out.

Are soft fermented pickles safe to eat? ›

It may be a normal reaction during fermentation caused by bacteria. If the pickles are soft, they are spoiled from the yeast fermentation. Don't use them. Using too weak a salt brine or vinegar solution may cause soft or slippery pickles, as can using moldy garlic or storing the pickles at too warm a temperature.

Should fermented pickles bubble? ›

The lactic acid fermentation process produces lactic acid bacteria that create gases when they feast on the vegetables. These gases are often visible as bubbles throughout the jar after a few days at room temperature and are a good sign.

Is fermented food fizzy? ›

On many of my recipes for fermented pickled veggies, I talk about how a sure sign of fermentation is in the bubbles and fizz that rise to the top of a canning jar as soon as you pop the lid. The lid is usually bubbled as the jar is filled with gas and thriving Lactobacillus bacteria.

Is cloudy pickle brine ok? ›

Some batches are naturally cloudier than others, but all are safe to consume and taste delicious. Shake Until Cloudy and Enjoy! Cloudy brine is a sign that you have a safe, successful, and tasty ferment. Even after all the pickles are gone and you have a jar of delicious brine leftover, don't toss it!

How do you know when pickles are done fermenting? ›

Within 1 week it should start to taste sour. If you like it, it is done. If not let it continue to ferment. Pack the vegetables back down until the liquid rises above them.

How long should pickles sit before eating? ›

Be patient.

Vinegar-preserved pickles may also need time: most refrigerated pickles taste best if they sit for at least 2 days, and processed pickles generally want to be stored a few weeks before they're open so that they fully develop their flavor.

How do I know when my pickles are ready? ›

To allow pickles to mellow and develop a delicious flavor, wait at least 3 weeks before eating! Keep in mind that pickles may be ready to enjoy earlier. It's all up to you and your tastes! Just don't let them go too long or the veggies' texture can deteriorate and turn rubbery.

Can you eat fizzing pickles? ›

The fizzy brine I experienced, Smith says, was likely a sign of microbial growth. “A lot of times when microorganisms grow, as part of the fermentation process they produce carbon dioxide gas,” she says. “And so definitely don't eat anything that's discolored or fizzing.”

Why is my pickle sizzling? ›

The fizzing when you opened them and the fact that they are soft and mushy is most likely due to enzyme activity from bacteria, yeasts and molds. And, since the bacteria Listeria monocytogenes can grow in acidic refrigerated pickles, there is a food safety risk involved.

When should you not eat pickles? ›

Sweet pickles aren't quite as high in sodium, but they still have plenty of it. And they're high in sugar. Because of their high levels of sodium, people who have heart issues should generally steer clear of pickles.

Why are my pickles fermented? ›

Quick pickles, the most common type of pickle found in grocery stores, are not fermented because they use an acid, such as vinegar, in their pickling brine. However, Lacto-fermented pickles are fermented because they follow the lactic acid fermentation method, which only uses water and salt in its brine.

Why is my ferment fizzy? ›

The lactic acid fermentation process produces lactic acid bacteria that create gases when they feast on the vegetables. These gases are often visible as bubbles throughout the jar after a few days at room temperature and are a good sign.

Do bubbies pickles go bad? ›

Once opened and if kept refrigerated, we recommend consuming the product within 3-4 months (our horseradish products within 2 months), though all should remain healthy to eat until each product's Expiration Date. For best results, keep all brined products submerged.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 6320

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.