The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (2024)

The Great British Bake Off will return for a 14th series on 26 September.

As summer unfolds into autumn GBBO is reliably comforting fare for this time of year and a welcome distraction, but that doesn’t mean it’s guaranteed to always be plain sailing.

Contestants interfering in each other’s bakes and blunders from the judges have raised the stakes — and undoubtedly blood pressure — for both bakers and viewers alike in past years.

Read more: Meet the Bake Off 2023 contestants

While the programme is a tried and tested formula, human unpredictability means drama could still be afoot even in the most gentle of shows.

So while viewers wait to see if there will be any cake catastrophes or dough disasters this year, let’s revisit the controversies of years gone by.

Paul Hollywood’s favouritism row

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (1)

The fourth series of the show in 2013 saw fans levy accusations of favouritism against Paul Hollywood as it was suggested he gave preferential treatment to then 21-year-old contestant Ruby Tandoh due to her looks.

He denied the claims with little tact, implying it couldn't be true because he found another contestant "far prettier".

Tandoh, who was runner-up to winner Frances Quinn, came out as gay in 2015 and criticised the “misogynists” who accused her of flirting with Hollywood at the time.

"For those who thought I fancied Paul Hollywood or that I'd ever bang him to get ahead – JOKE'S ON YOU, YOU MASSIVE S****ING MISOGYNISTS," she wrote.

Custardgate

Deborah Manger was a dentist-turned-baker-turned-accidental-thief when she unwittingly took poor Howard Middleton's custard in series four.

She owned up to the mistake to Sue Perkins after pinching from her competitor, who took the news rather graciously, as they made a trifle for their first challenge of Dessert Week.

Middleton used Manger's custard for his creation as it was too late to retrieve the one he’d made but the judges were made aware of the mistake and so they were judged on the custard of their own making.

He managed to make it through to another week while Manger left the tent for good.

The baked Alaska fiasco

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (3)

Diana Beard stirred up a storm on series five when it appeared she had taken Iain Watters' Baked Alaska ice cream out of the freezer.

A frustrated Iain threw his creation into the bin and even presented said disposal unit to the judges when it was time to bring his bake up to the front of the tent.

It provoked national outrage though as Beard’s apparent devious actions hit the headlines.

However, all might not have been as it seemed as in the wake of the backlash Sue Perkins stated the ice cream had barely been out of the freezer.

"Iain's Alaska was out of the freezer for 40 secs. That's it. No sabotage. 40 secs of normal temp would NOT be enough to reduce it to liquid," she wrote.

Iain's Alaska was out of the freezer for 40 secs. That's it. No sabotage. 40 secs of normal temp would NOT be enough to reduce it to liquid

— Sue Perkins (@sueperkins) August 27, 2014

Beard quit the show – which had been filmed in the spring – before the next episode due to reasons unrelated to the dessert drama with Iain later expressing dismay at the way she had been treated online.

Although he did also tell The Guardian he didn’t believe the programme-maker’s claims the dessert was out of the freezer for only 40 seconds.

Channel 4 change-up

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (4)

GBBO found great success on BBC Two and so was promoted to BBC One after four series, but in 2016 the programme's makers Love Productions jumped ship to Channel 4 after a disagreement over price.

Mary Berry, Perkins and Mel Giedroyc stayed loyal to the BBC while Hollywood followed the programme to Channel 4.

The split in the original GBBO team appeared to be a source of friction for the foursome as Hollywood claimed Berry, Perkins and Giedroyc had "abandoned" the programme while he became "the most hated man in the country".

Read more: All the Bake Off winners and where they are now

Earlier this year, Perkins reflected on the divide, describing the fallout with the baker as "painful" although didn't delve into the nitty-gritty of what went on.

Speaking on Jessie Ware’s Table Manners podcast, she said: “When we were there, Paul was really good fun - and stuff happened that made us incredibly sad and incredibly hurt.

“But he was always like family for years and years and years, and it’s painful when those things end, especially in the way that they did end.”

Noel Fielding’s fridge antics

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (5)

Noel Fielding was brought onto the programme on its move to Channel 4 but he got off to a bit of a rocky start on his debut season.

While playing around in the big white tent, his co-star Sandi Toksvig opened a fridge to reveal the comedian crouched inside in a move that prompted 55 complaints to Ofcom.

Some feared the joke could prove harmful if children attempted to copy his actions, however, the broadcasting watchdog decided the programme did not need to be investigated.

Prue Leith's premature announcement

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (6)

The first series of GBBO to air on Channel 4 had its finale overshadowed somewhat by a Twitter blunder made by new judge Prue Leith.

Ahead of the airing of the final episode which saw Sophie Faldo win the coveted cake stand, Leith congratulated her in a tweet.

After realising her error the cook apologised and explained she was in a different timezone as she holidayed in Bhutan.

She later described her mishap as "the most idiotic thing in the world" – but it can't have been too bad in Channel 4's eyes as they kept her on for more.

Series 14 of The Great British Bake Off starts tonight, Tuesday, 26 September at 8pm on Channel 4.

The biggest Bake Off controversies over the years (2024)

FAQs

What is the biggest Great British Bake Off controversy? ›

Paul Hollywood's favouritism row. The fourth series of the show in 2013 saw fans levy accusations of favouritism against Paul Hollywood as it was suggested he gave preferential treatment to then 21-year-old contestant Ruby Tandoh due to her looks.

What illness did Noel Fielding have? ›

In 2009, a Sunday Times article revealed that Fielding developed alcohol-induced hepatitis during his college years; he said that he was helped through this time by his friend and collaborator Nigel Coan. This forced him not to drink alcohol for six months, which led him to become teetotal for a couple of years.

Why did Sandi Toksvig leave Bake Off? ›

At the time, Toksvig said she was leaving “to spend more time with my other work”. As my waistline will testify, Bake Off is an all-consuming show,” she said in her statement. “Spending time with Prue [Leith], Paul [Hollywood] and Noel has been one of the great pleasures of my life.

Why did Prue leave the Great British Baking Show? ›

Channel 4 confirmed that Prue would be stepping back from Celebrity Bake Off in a statement provided to The Independent which read: “Prue will be joining Paul as usual to judge The Great British Bake Off but will be stepping back from The Great Celebrity Bake Off for Stand Up To Cancer.” Celebrity chef Nigella Lawson ...

Why did Noel leave Bake Off? ›

He explained that it had become too much of a struggle juggling his various TV commitments. “Farewell Bake Off!” he wrote in a statement. “It's been a delicious experience and I can't imagine a more fun way of spending my summers.

Who sabotaged on The Great British Baking Show? ›

Number of times named Star Baker

She met her husband Malcolm when she was 16 and they are still happily married. Diana found herself at the center of the "Bingate" controversy, where she was accused of sabotage after removing her fellow contestant Iain Watters' dessert from the freezer to make space for her own.

Why was Noel Fielding missing from Bake Off final? ›

According to his co-host Matt Lucas, Noel wouldn't be appearing on the first day of the final because he 'was feeling under the weather'.

Why did Matt leave Bake Off? ›

Matt Lucas is leaving Great British Bake Off

Matt Lucas announced he would no longer appear on my emotional support baking competition and it's, well, a start. From my view, Lucas's humor—which trended toward edginess and cringe—just wasn't compatible with what makes the show great.

Is Noel Fielding religious? ›

Fielding once stated that he was never baptised, he hasn't got a middle name and he does not follow any religion.

Who is replacing Sandi Toksvig on Bake Off? ›

Toksvig announced her departure from the programme in 2020 and was replaced by comedian Matt Lucas, with Alison Hammond later taking over his role last year. The Denmark-born broadcaster told the Radio Times: “To be honest, I left Bake Off because I stopped having fun.

Who did Noel replace on Bake Off? ›

The 50-year-old comedian has been a co-host of the long-running Channel 4 show since 2017 - initially presenting the show alongside Danish comedienne Sandi Toksvig, 65. Sandi quit the show when she grew bored of it - walking away at the end of 2019 and then being replaced by 49-year-old Little Britain star Matt.

What happened to Jo from Bake Off? ›

Jo Wheatley (2011)

Wheatley took the Bake Off crown following an all-female final and has gone on to release two bestselling cookery books, A Passion for Baking and Home Baking. The mum of three, 49, has also appeared on The One Show and The Alan Titchmarsh show and has written for the Sun and Sainsbury's Magazine.

Why is Prue in a wheelchair? ›

I have snapped my Achilles tendon. Moments later, the show's medic came to Prue's aid and got “to use his ambulance, wheelchair, and considerable skills.” After doctors diagnosed Prue's injury, they gave her a boot to wear until it healed up and told her to use either a wheelchair or crutches when moving around.

Why was Prue replaced with Paige? ›

Producers then decided to kill off Prue and replace her with a long-lost younger half-sister named Paige Matthews (played by Rose McGowan), in favor of having "a fresh face" join the series. The producers had to re-cut the season three cliffhanger to explain Prue's sudden disappearance.

Did Prue Leith have a Michelin star? ›

In 2023, Leith also received criticism for one of her signature expressions — "worth the calories" — as some said it promoted disordered eating. Even so, Leith's career is impressive and filled with accomplishments, perhaps most notably earning a Michelin Star.

Why is Great British Bake Off cancelled? ›

The show, which first aired in 2010, has been cancelled to make way for live football. Hosted by Alison Hammond and Noel Fielding, the show will move from its regular slot to tomorrow. And tonight, football fans will be able to watch England go head to head against Italy for the Euro 2024 qualifying games.

What is the illness in the Great British Bake Off? ›

She was then rushed outside. A tearful Tasha was comforted by new host Alison Hammond. Tasha was filmed having a discussion with the camera crew and revealed she had suffered with a migraine the night before. The decision was made for her to go home.

What happened to the bald guy on The Great British Baking Show? ›

Lucas announced his departure from the series in a tweet on Tuesday, saying that he simply couldn't juggle his other commitments, including an appearance in the upcoming reboot of British TV show Fantasy Football League, and his Bake Off hosting duties at the same time.

Why did Netflix change the name of Great British Bake Off? ›

American audiences on PBS and Netflix know the show as The Great British Baking Show, but in the U.K., the show airs under its original name, The Great British Bake-Off. So why the change? It all comes down to copyright.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 5783

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.