Battle of the Pies: How to Choose the Healthiest Pie and Why - Who's On The Move (2024)

Battle of the Pies: How to Choose the Healthiest Pie and Why - Who's On The Move (1)

By Kay MacInnis

Nothing says fall like the smell of pie baking in the oven. And if you’re getting ready for the holidays, I’m sure you are experiencing this first-hand.

But a word of warning: Here in South Carolina, we rank in the top 10 nationally for the highest rates of adult obesity, diabetes, and hypertension. Our child obesity rate is second in the nation. This raises the question: With Thanksgiving approaching, how can we best enjoy those warm pies without completely destroying our health?

It can be done.

Let’s compare some of our favorites:

Pecan Pie: There is a lot of buzz suggesting that eating more nuts is good for our health. That’s fine. In the case of pecan pie, it is the corn syrup that you need to limit. One slice of pecan pie contains 410-450 calories.

Tip: For nearly half the sugar, try using light agave nectar instead of corn syrup.

Apple Pie: While the “apple” part makes it sound healthier, one slice contains 411 calories. That is just about a meal’s worth of calories, and 42 percent of these calories come from fat.

Tip: Skip the top crust. Then make the bottom crust with a crumb mixture made of 1/2 cup whole-wheat flour, a cup of crushed Kellogg’s Special K cereal, 6 tablespoons of applesauce, 2 tablespoons of butter-flavored olive oil, and a half teaspoon of brown sugar.

Pumpkin Pie: This one is our winner! When in doubt, choose pumpkin pie. In competition with those mentioned above, it offers the fewest calories, and least fat and added sugar. It’s also loaded with vitamins and minerals such as vitamin B12, thiamin, riboflavin, folate, niacin, phosphorous, calcium, and iron.

See Also
Pecan Pie

Tip: To make it even healthier, check out the recipe below.

Pumpkin Pie

Ingredients:

  • 1½ cup canned pumpkin
  • ¾ cup packed light brown sugar
  • 1 tbsp. cornstarch
  • 1 tsp. ground cinnamon
  • ¼ tsp. ground nutmeg
  • ¼ tsp. salt (optional)
  • 1 tsp. vanilla extract
  • 2 eggs or 4 egg whites
  • 1 can evaporated lowfat milk

Ginger snap pie crust:

  • 20 (1¾ cup) ginger snaps, crushed
  • 2½ tbsp. unsalted butter or butter-flavored olive oil
  • 2 tbsp. white sugar

Preparation:

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  • Combine cookie crumbs, sugar and melted butter in a 9-inch pie pan.
  • Bake for 5 minutes. Cool completely before filling with pie filling.
  • Combine all filling ingredients and blend with wire whisk until combined.
  • Pour pie filling into crust and bake for 45 minutes at 350 degrees, or until pie is firm.
  • Cool and serve.

Nutritional information: 273 Calories, 11.3 grams fat, 246.55 mg. sodium and 11 mg. cholesterol

………………………………………………………

This is another in a weekly series of healthy recipes from Kay MacInnis, registered dietitian at Providence Hospitals in Columbia.

Kay works in Health and Wellness at Providence, helping cardiac and diabetes patients eat their way to healthier lives. She’s not a chef herself, but in consultation with the actual chefs at Providence, she’s learned a lot over the years as she has worked to help patients help themselves after they leave the hospital.

She also conducts a number of health and wellness events for the public, including the monthly Providence Cooks! classes.

Battle of the Pies: How to Choose the Healthiest Pie and Why - Who's On The Move (2)

Sign up hereto start your free subscription to MidlandsLife!

.

Battle of the Pies: How to Choose the Healthiest Pie and Why - Who's On The Move (2024)

FAQs

What type of pie is the healthiest? ›

When in doubt, choose pumpkin pie. In competition with those mentioned above, it offers the fewest calories, and least fat and added sugar.

How were the first pies different from the pie's we eat today? ›

The early Greeks and Romans enjoyed pie over 6,000 years ago yet it differs from what we know today. The pies were savory containing meats instead of fruits. After sugar became more available and cheaper in the 1500s, fruit began to be included. Earlier pies did not have the type of crusts we have today.

Who makes the best pie? ›

Nice Slice: 36 Favorite Pies from Coast to Coast
  • 1 / 36. Dutch Apple Pie from Julian Pie Company: Julian, California. ...
  • 2 / 36. Strawberry-Balsamic Pie from Bramble Pies: Boise, Idaho. ...
  • 3 / 36. Chocolate Meringue Pie from Sugaree's: New Albany, Mississippi. ...
  • 4 / 36. Photo: Aaron Ottis.

Which pie has the least calories? ›

So what's a pie aficionado to do? Well, if you want to consume fewer calories, go for the pumpkin—it almost always has fewer because of the single crust. You could also take a sliver of both pies.

Is pumpkin pie or apple pie better for you? ›

The pumpkin pie wins on calories, saturated fat, protein and calcium. But the apple pie takes the cake when it comes to fiber, sugar (both total and added) and sodium. So what's a pie aficionado to do? Well, if you're watching calories go for the pumpkin-it almost always has fewer because of the single crust.

Which is healthier pecan pie or pumpkin pie? ›

Pecan pie contains more calories but offers you plenty of nutrients that you can't find in any other pie. On the other hand, pumpkin pies have a lower calorie content. But pumpkins contain fewer nutrients compared to pecans. Hence, both of these pies are healthy in their own way.

What is the oldest pie in the world? ›

The Ancient Egyptians were the first to invent a dish close to what we know as a pie today. They had a honey filling covered in a crusty cake made from oats, wheat, rye or barley. A recipe for chicken pie was also discovered on a tablet carved prior to 2000 BC.

Why did they put birds in pies? ›

A pie bird is a hollow ceramic or stoneware tool that is placed in the center of pies to prevent the filling from bubbling over.

Why were pies called coffins? ›

A coffin or coffyn referred to a container made of pastry, a precursor of the modern pie crust, and food was served in the coffin it had been cooked in. The first printed use of the word coffin as a box for a corpse appeared later, in the 16th century. Historians trace pies back to ancient times.

What is the #1 pie in the US? ›

Apple. There are five states they prefer apple pie to other flavors. Apples came to the United States with Europeans. Apple pie has English origins, according to Smithsonian magazine, but the dessert is an American classic.

What is the least popular pie in the United States? ›

The least popular types of pies were salted caramel, gooseberry, blueberry and peach, all being the most popular in only one state each.

Who makes McDonald's pies? ›

All of the pies sold at US McDonald's are made in Tulsa. For more than 50 years, all the pies sold in US McDonald's have been made exclusively at Bama Companies in Tulsa, Oklahoma. (Bama also makes biscuits and hotcakes for the fast-food chain.)

What is the unhealthiest pie? ›

Usually a pastry top but it can be meringue in lemon meringue pie or potato in shepherds pie. Otherwise, it's a tart. The most unhealthy “pie” is treacle tart. This is wall-to-wall sugar in a pastry base.

What makes pies unhealthy? ›

Sadly, they're not great as a regular part of your diet. An average individual meat pie provides around 450kcal, but the biggest problem is the 12g of saturated fat inside it – that's more than half the daily guideline. If you have buttery mashed potato or chips on the side, the fat content of your meal is even higher.

Is pie healthier than cake? ›

If you eat a whole cake, you will probably get a sugar rush and pass out because it is too much, with how much frosting and extra sugary things that are added, whereas if you eat a whole pie, there won't be as much of a problem, because it is not all sugar.

What is the healthiest pastry option? ›

Even better, switch your pastry from shortcrust or puff to filo. This is the lowest-fat pastry by far, with 2.9g fat per 100g. This compares with 26.2g for puff or 31.4g for shortcrust. Filo is the lowest-calorie option too, and it's easy to use.

Is sweet potato pie or pumpkin pie healthier? ›

Between the two pies, most of the other ingredients are the same. Pumpkin pie has slightly lower calories, while sweet potato pie has more nutrients.

Is pie healthy or unhealthy? ›

Why are pies unhealthy? It is true pies have fat in them and therefore we always recommend that pies should be consumed as part of a balanced diet. The fat is primarily found in the pastry and is a critical ingredient.

Is pecan pie healthier than apple pie? ›

With an astounding 620 calories per slice, pecan pie dominates the contest from a caloric standpoint. Pecans themselves provide a wide variety of vitamins and minerals and are thought to be healthy for the heart.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6005

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.